1. Introduction
1-1
Objectives
1-2
Seeds of Ethnic Cleansing Administrative
Divisions of
1-3
Ethnic Cleansing
1-4
Others are hell
1-5
The Right of Return
1-6
Note on documentation
1.1 Objectives:
This web site, the “ villagesofpalestine.com
”, (VOPC) is a private, independent website unaffiliated with any political
party or governmental organization. The VOPC aims to bring the information
about the villages of Palestine from books, shelves, live memories and any
other available source into the Internet. This will introduce the tragedy of
the Palestinian people to a larger global audience, on the one hand, and
ensures any easy accessible reference for those Palestinians who are born in
Diaspora, namely in the non-Arab countries, on the other hand.
My ambition is to
collect, compile and disseminate information – via the Internet - about the
villages of Palestine whether destroyed or in existence. Our referential guide in identifying these
villages is the Supplement No.2 to the Palestine Gazette No.1415 of June 7,
1945 published by the Government of Palestine then. This supplement contains the administrative
divisions of all Palestine and the names of the cities, towns, villages and
Bedouin tribes, which existed in the country in 1945(1)
1.2 Seeds of
Ethnic Cleansing:
In the early years of the Zionists efforts
to secure support for their enterprise, they propagated the idea of “ a land
without people for a people without a land.” a slogan coined by Israel Zagwill,
a prominent Anglo-Jewish writer. (2) Even Bin-Gurion, one of the Founding
Fathers of Israel, writes in his “Memories” negating the very existence of the
Palestinian people in Palestine:
“I believed then,
as I do today, that we held a clear title to this country [Palestine]. Not the
right to take it away from others (there were no others)[emphasis
added], but the right and the duty to fill its emptiness, restore life to its
barrenness, to re-create a modern version of our ancient Israel.”(3)
Despite such
propaganda, the Founding Fathers from the outset were well aware that not only
there were people on the land, but also that people were there in large
numbers. (4) The facts and figures presented below regarding the villages of
Palestine refute this fallacy of empty barren land, “ a land without people “
and show the magnitude of the premeditated Israeli ethnic cleansing
committed against the Palestinians in 1948 and later on up to this moment.
1.3
Administrative Divisions of Palestine in 1945:
According to the Proclamation of the High
Commissioner for Palestine published in the Palestine Gazette no, 1415 of the 7th
of June 1945, there were six districts and 16 sub-districts in Palestine(5)
Galilee
District composed of the five sub-districts of Acre, Beisan, Nazareth,
Safad and Tiberias.
1.
Haifa
District, coextensive with Haifa sub-district.
2.
Samaria
District, composed of the sub-districts of Jenin, Nablus and Tulkarm.
3.
Jerusalem
District, composed of the three sub-districts of Hebron, Jerusalem and
Ramallah.
4.
Lydda
District, composed of the sub-districts of Jaffa and Ramle;
5.
Gaza
District, composed of sub-districts of BeerSheba and Gaza.
“British Mandate
officials translated the Ottoman Arabic term qada’ as “sub district” and called
the larger unit encompassing it, the liwa’, “district”. . . .Government
statistics about villages were gathered at the level of qada’ and were recorded
under this heading; hence the qada’ is the most important unit for data on
village life. We translated the term as
‘district’ in preference to the more precise but clumsier sub district.”(6)
I will be using “district” as is used in All That Remains i.e. as a translation
of qada’.
1.4 Ethnic Cleansing:
The following summary shows the number of
towns and villages in each district in 1948; the Arab towns and villages
occupied by the Israelis; the number of Arab towns and villages destroyed; the
number of Arab towns and villages still in existence in Israel; and the number
of Arab towns and villages which exist in the West Bank and Gaza.(7)
|
|
No of Arab towns and villages in 1948, excluding Bedouin localities |
Arab towns and villages occupied by Zionists 1948-49 |
Arab Towns and Villages destroyed |
Arab Towns and villages still existing in Israel |
Arab towns and Villages in the West Bank and Gaza |
|
1.Acre |
50 |
50 |
23 |
27 |
00 |
|
2. Beisan |
30 |
30 |
27 |
3 |
00 |
|
3. Nazareth |
27 |
27 |
8 |
19 |
00 |
|
4. Safad |
78 |
78 |
73 |
5 |
00 |
|
5. Tiberias |
31 |
31 |
26 |
5 |
00 |
|
6. Hafia |
58 |
58 |
42 |
16 |
00 |
|
7. Jenin |
67 |
19 |
7 |
12 |
48 |
|
8. Nablus |
106 |
5 |
2 |
3 |
101 |
|
9. Tulkarm |
87 |
35 |
25 |
10 |
52 |
|
10. Hebron |
37 |
18 |
18 |
None |
19 |
|
11. Jerusalem |
85 |
43 |
42 |
1 |
42 |
|
12. Ramallah |
39 |
None |
None |
None |
36 |
|
13. Haffa |
24 |
24 |
24 |
None |
00 |
|
14.Ramle |
59 |
59 |
59 |
None |
00 |
|
15.Beersheba |
2 |
2 |
2 |
None |
00 |
|
16. Gaza |
56 |
47 |
47 |
None |
9 |
|
Total |
833 |
526 |
425 |
101 |
307 |
As
shown above, about 81% of the occupied villages were demolished and evicted by
force. The population was uprooted, expelled to other places, and condemned to
estrangement, poverty, illness and endless human sufferings caused by
expulsion. This ethnic cleansing,
indeed, took place according to a very well prepared plan executed without
mercy. Yosef Weitz, member of the Jewish Agency’s First Transfer Committee,
wrote in his diary (entry dated 12 January 1948):
The Land of Israel is not small at all, if only the Arabs will be removed and if its frontiers would be enlarged a
little; to the north all the way to the Litani[River in Lebanon], and to the
east by including the Golan Heights…While the Arabs should be transferred to northern Syria and Iraq. (8)
[Emphasis added]
Even a list of the
villages to be cleared out was ready in 1930 according to Weitz transfer Plan.
I made a summary of a list of the Arab villages, which in my opinion must be
cleared out in order to complete Jewish regions. I also made a summary of the
places that have land disputes and must be settled by military means. (9)
According to Mr.
Weitz , the Palestinians and the Israelis are mutually exclusive in the same
land. He is firmly convinced that there
is no room for the Israelis and Palestinians living togather in Palestine as he
writes in his dairy entry dated 20 December 1940:
Amongst ourselves
it must be clear that there is no room for both peoples in this country.[emphasis
added]. No ”development” will bring us closer to our aim to be an
independent people in this small
Country. After the Arabs are
transferred, the country will be wide and open for us; with the Arabs staying
the country will remain narrow and
restricted…. There is no room for compromise on this point….land
purchasing….will not bring about the state;….The only way is transfer the Arabs from here to neighboring
countries, all of them, except perhaps Bethlehem, Nazareth, and old Jerusalem. Not a single village or a single tribe must
be left. And the transfer must be
done through their absorption in Iraq
and Syria and even in Trans Jordan.
For that goal money will be found- even a lot of money. And only then will the country be
able to absorb millions of Jews…. There is no other solution.(10) [emphasis
added]
1.5 “Others Are Hell”
It is evident that the Palestinian refugee
crises is, indeed, a result of design not war.(11)
It is the
substitution of one people for another by force of arms,(12) the endless long
columns of refugees fleeting toward the Lebanese borders before we joined them in Lebanon are still vivid in
my memory. The strong feeling of being uprooted
and expelled from our homeland is the driving force in our daily life, hence,
the relentless determination to return to our homeland, rebuild our destroyed
villages and embrace its sacred soil. We were forced to leave our homeland 52
years ago. Time has been entrapped in the moment of our expulsion. Thus we live in continuous tragic human
sufferings. This is a Promethean image
of the Palestinian refugees with one exception: We did not steal fire from
gods. The Israelis took our land from us
by force and condemned us to this everlasting torture. In addition to this, the Israelis and their
allies want us to legalize their act of ethnic cleansing and unlawfully
possession of our homes and land. What a tragedy of human consciousness!!! No language can capture the tragic dimensions
of our human sufferings. “ Others are hell.”…”Others are hell”. .” Others are
hell”.
1.6 The Right of Return
One of the hard facts facing the Palestinian
Authority and the Israelis is the “Right of Return”. The right of return and
/or compensation as provided for under UN Resolution 194 of 1948 is the only
feasible option for reconciliation and peace acceptable to the 4.5 million
alienated refugees living in Diaspora in the Arab world and beyond. They are
prey to poverty, illness, misery, torture, oppression and worst of these sufferings
and grievances: fragmentation. The right of return is an individualistic
right. It is nontransferable to others,
can’t be annihilated, despised, or confiscated by any authority “ The
sanctity of private ownership supersedes any legislation”.
No one, even
Arafat, has the authority to relinquish our holy right of return to our
homeland.
Any Palestinian
Authority who may do a deal with Israel on the refugees and betrays the right
of return is, indeed, without real legitimacy and will be condemned and isolated
by the Palestinians. Mr. Asaad
Abdel-Rahman, the PLO’s minister in charge of the refugee question for the
peace process shares millions of the Palestinian refugees their worries about
this matter as Professor Edward Said tells us:
Asaad Abdel-Rahman,
the PLO’s minister in charge of the refugee question for the peace process, has
recently made some excellent strong statements about the absolute right of
return for Palestinians evicted by Israel: these statements express the right
kind of resolve and the right kind of moral indignation. After all, Abdel-Rahman says, a UN resolution
(number 194) has been affirmed annually since 1948; it allows Palestinians the
right of return and/or compensation. Why should there be a compromise by
Palestinians given the world community’s unanimity? Even the US has supported
the resolution, with Israel the lone dissenter. The troubling thing,
however, is that Abdel-Rahman hints that the PlO leadership may do a deal with
Israel on the refugees behind his back which, in view of the long history of
shabby Arafatian compromises whose net effect have been to sell out his people,
is an allowable, not to say perfectly well-founded worry. (13)
The Palestinian
exodus of 1948 is the Heart of the Palestinian question. “ If the Palestinian
Diaspora, which is composed of a majority of refugees is not the beneficiary of
this ‘peace process,’ why must it acquiesce in it by conceding all its rights?
To ask the Diaspora and the refugees to
sacrifice their right, hopes, and dreams,
so that some meager political
benefits can accrue to native
West Bank and Gaza Palestinians is to ask the Diaspora and refugees more generally, to commit
national suicide.” (14)
United Nations
Partition of Palestine (29th November 1947) gave 46% of Palestine to
the Palestinians and gave 52% of Palestine to Israel. In the 1948 war, Israel
occupied the Upper Galilee, and the total area occupied by Israel became 79% of
Palestine. On the 5th of June
1967, Israel occupied the rest 21% of Palestine known as Gaza Strip and the
West Bank. The Palestinian State proposed by the Palestinian Authority is on
the 21% of Palestine (Gaza Strip and
the West Bank). Total population of Gaza and the West Bank is 3,215,889. 1,327,920
are refugees registered with UNRWA. The number of the local population ( non
refugees status) is 1,887,969. Simple
calculation shows that the proposed state will be for 22% of the Palestinian
people on 21% of Palestine as the following tables show (Shaml
Website-Palestinian Refugees Distribution) :
|
REFUGEES REGISTERED WITH UNRWA |
||||||
|
Field |
No. of Camps |
Refugees Inside Camps |
Refugees Inside Camps |
Refugees Outside Camps |
Total No. of Refugees |
Refugees' proportion of local population |
|
10 |
269,749 |
18,4 |
1,193,315 |
1,463,064 |
33,3 % |
|
|
19 |
147,015 |
26,5 |
408,042 |
555,057 |
29,7 % |
|
|
8 |
423,881 |
54,9 |
348,982 |
772,863 |
75,7 % |
|
|
12 |
198,931 |
54,6 |
165,620 |
364,551 |
10,4 % |
|
|
SYRIA (SAR) |
10 |
106,748 |
29,2 |
258, 857 |
365,605 |
2,5 % |
|
Total all Fields |
59 |
1,146,324 |
|
2,374,816 |
3,521,140 |
|
|
Source: UNRWA in Figures, UNRWA HQ, September
1998 |
|
Distribution of Palestinian Population Worldwide |
|
PALESTINE
|
1,869,818 |
|
Total Inside Palestine* |
4,169,386 |
|
DIASPORA
|
2,328,308 |
|
Total Outside Palestine** |
4,233,637 |
|
|
8,403,023 |
|
* Source: PCBS, Population
Census, 1997 |
Let us hope that
the Palestinian Authority remains steadfast
to our “ Right of Return” and
will never offer the “ Palestinian Refugees ” as a burnt sacrifice in the temple of the
Israelis arrogance of power. Our homes and lands in Jaffa, Haifa,
Safad, Kafr Biri’m and other towns and
villages have the same sanctity as Jerusalem. “ No claim dies as long there is someone to
keep up that claim,” as an Arab proverb says.
The Palestinians in Diaspora and in Palestine will keep up this claim
until the “Right of Return” is
implemented.
1.7 Note on
Documentation:
The core of data has been extracted from the following sources:
All that Remains,
al-Mawsu’a al-Filastinya (Encyclopedia of Palestine), Encyclopedia of the
Palestine Problem, al-Dabbagh’s Biladuna Filastin, and the Palestinian Oxodus
from Galilee 1948.
The extracted
passages from these sources will not be specifically identified in the text
itself. The source(s) will be referred to at the end of each village
text.. The original authors preserve
all the copyrights of these texts.
In presenting data I will start from the upper north i.e. Safad
District,then Acre District and so on…
Windsor, this 24th of August, 1999
Footnotes:
1.
Issa
Nakhleh, Encyclopedia of the Palestine Problem, vo.1, Washington D.C.:
Institute for Palestine Studies. 1993, p.293.
2.
Nor
Masaliha, Expulsion of the Palestinians, The Concept of “Transfer” in Zionist
Political Thought 1882-1948. Washington D.C.: Institute for Palestine
Studies,1992, p.5
3.
David
Ben-Gurion, Memoirs, New York and Cleveland: the World Publishing Company,1970,
P26
4.
Masalha,
Expulsion, p 6
5.
Nakhleh,
Encyclopedia, vol.1, pp 305-306
6.
Walid
Khalidi, Editor, All that Remains: the Palestinian Villages Occupied and
Depopulated by Israel in 1948.Washington D.C.: Institute of Palestine
Studies,1992.p xx
7.
Nakhleh,
Encyclopedia, Vol.1, p. 332
8.
Masalha,
Expulsion, p. 134
9.
Ibid,
p.186
10. For a different point of view see: Benny Morris, the Birth of
the Palestinian Refugee Problem,
1947-1949
11.
Maslha, Expulsion, pp131-132
12. Rashid
Khaldi, Intod., The Palestinian Exodus from Galilee by Hafez Nazzal Beirut: the Institute of
Palestine Studies, 1978, p5
13
Edward Said, “ the right of return at last.”, Feb 10, 2000 p.2 in Arabic
Media Internet Network.
14 Joseph Massad, “ Return or Permanent Exile? Palestinian Refugees and the Ends of
Oslo.”p.5 See the whole paper in
Critique, Spring 1999,pp. 5-23.